Email Deliverability Case Study: AI Sales Platform Success Story
AI sales platform deliverability transformed: How we recovered inbox placement from 43% to 81% for an AI SDR tool, saved $840K in at-risk ARR, and built robust email infrastructure for multi-tenant SaaS at scale
This case study represents a composite of multiple client engagements to protect confidential client information while accurately reflecting the outcomes and methodologies Postbox Services delivers for AI-native, high-volume platforms.
Who We Help
We work with fast-growing products where email deliverability is critical to the value they deliver.
AI-powered sales & outreach tools
Platforms that use agents and automated workflows to run large-scale outbound email and multi-channel prospecting for B2B sales teams.
Sequences & multi-channel outreach
Products that orchestrate email sequences, follow-ups, and prospect journeys across different mailboxes and domains at scale.
Demo & asset-driven workflows
Platforms that rely on email to deliver interactive demos, trial experiences, or content that sales teams send at high volume.
The AI Sales Platform Deliverability Challenge
A rapidly growing AI sales platform was experiencing critical deliverability issues that threatened their core product value proposition. As an AI SDR email solution powering automated outbound campaigns for 150+ B2B customers and sending millions of emails monthly through a multi-tenant SaaS email infrastructure, their inbox placement rates were in free fall—and with them, customer confidence.
The Breaking Point
In Q2 2024, the platform’s inbox placement rate dropped from 78% to 43% over a three-week period. Customer complaints surged, with support tickets containing phrases like:
Root Causes Identified
- Multi-tenant SaaS email deliverability failure: One customer’s aggressive sending pattern tanked domain reputation for all users on shared infrastructure
- Automated outbound email throttling: Volume ramping too quickly without proper warmup protocols caused Gmail to severely limit delivery
- Sales engagement platform email infrastructure gaps: No domain rotation strategy, insufficient monitoring, and reactive (not proactive) reputation management
- Scaling constraints: Adding new customers required manual provisioning and created single points of failure
Business Impact
The AI Sales Platform Deliverability Solution
Postbox Services implemented a comprehensive AI sales platform deliverability transformation and ongoing email infrastructure management program—specifically designed for multi-tenant SaaS email environments running automated outbound email at scale.
Phase 1: Emergency Stabilization (Weeks 1-2)
Immediate Triage
- Conducted deep infrastructure audit across all sending domains and mailboxes
- Identified 12 domains with critical reputation issues requiring immediate quarantine
- Implemented emergency domain rotation to isolate problem accounts
Quick Wins
- Deployed real-time monitoring for domain and IP reputation scores
- Established complaint feedback loops with major ISPs
- Created temporary sending pools to stabilize delivery for high-value customers
Phase 2: Infrastructure Rebuild (Weeks 3-5)
Multi-Tenant Domain Architecture
- Designed and deployed segmented domain pools by customer risk profile
- Implemented domain rotation logic to prevent single-customer contamination
- Established separate warmup and production pools for controlled scaling
Mailbox Pool Optimization
- Sourced and provisioned 500+ compliant Gmail and Outlook mailboxes
- Built automated warmup engine with progressive volume ramping
- Implemented mailbox health scoring and automatic rotation for underperforming accounts
Authentication & Compliance
- Properly configured DKIM, SPF, and DMARC across all sending domains
- Achieved full authentication alignment for major ISPs
- Established domain aging protocols for new additions
Phase 3: Operational Management (Weeks 6-8 & Ongoing)
Daily Operations Offshored
- Daily warmup execution and health monitoring
- Proactive blocklist and spam trap detection
- Weekly inbox placement testing via seed lists
- Complaint and bounce rate monitoring with automated alerts
Continuous Improvement
- Monthly deliverability optimization reviews
- Sending pattern analysis and recommendation
- Customer onboarding protocols to prevent future reputation incidents
- Engineering team training on deliverability best practices
AI Sales Platform Deliverability Results & ROI
Quantitative Outcomes
Growth Enablement
- Successfully onboarded 40+ new enterprise customers in 90 days post-stabilization
- Scaled from 2.5M to 6.8M emails per month without infrastructure incidents
- Unlocked $2.1M in new ARR that was previously blocked
- Engineering team freed up from 60 hours/week to <5 hours/week on email issues
Qualitative Outcomes
Engineering Team Feedback
“Before Postbox, our engineers were constantly pulled away from product development to fix email fires. Now they can focus on building AI features while deliverability just works in the background.”
— VP of Engineering
Customer Success Impact
“We went from defensive conversations about why emails weren’t delivering to proactive discussions about scaling volume. The confidence our customers have in the platform completely changed.”
— Head of Customer Success
Revenue Team Benefits
“Email deliverability used to be a deal-killer in enterprise sales conversations. Now it’s a competitive advantage. We can confidently commit to inbox placement SLAs.”
— Chief Revenue Officer
Technical Implementation Details
Infrastructure Stack Deployed
Sending Layer
- Google Workspace + Microsoft 365 + AWS SES for SMTP relay
- Custom domain pool management system
- Automated mailbox provisioning and rotation
- Multi-tier warmup engine (conservative, moderate, aggressive profiles)
Monitoring & Observability
- Real-time reputation scoring for domains and IPs
- Automated blocklist monitoring (100+ lists checked hourly)
- Seed list testing across Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo, and 15+ ISPs
- Complaint feedback loop integration with major providers
Multi-Tenant Isolation
- Customer risk profiling algorithm (sending patterns, complaint rates, engagement)
- Dynamic domain assignment based on risk score
- Automatic quarantine triggers for problematic accounts
- Separate infrastructure for trial vs. paid customers
Operational Playbooks Created
- Customer Onboarding Protocol: Pre-flight checks before enabling sending
- Incident Response Playbook: Rapid triage for sudden deliverability drops
- Scaling Checklist: Requirements for increasing volume by 50%+
- Quarterly Health Review: Proactive optimization recommendations
Key Success Factors
What Made This Transformation Work
Speed of Response
Postbox deployed emergency fixes within 72 hours of engagement. Full infrastructure rebuild completed in 5 weeks (not 5 months). Continuous improvements shipped weekly, not quarterly.
Domain Expertise
Deep understanding of multi-tenant deliverability challenges. Experience with AI-powered sending platforms and their unique patterns. Relationships with ISP teams for rapid issue escalation.
Full-Stack Ownership
Single point of accountability from infrastructure to daily operations. No finger-pointing between vendors when issues arose. Proactive monitoring caught problems before customers noticed.
Partnership Approach
Weekly sync with engineering team during buildout. Knowledge transfer so internal team understood the system. Collaborative problem-solving rather than black-box service delivery.
Long-Term Partnership
Ongoing Management (Months 3-12)
After the initial transformation, Postbox continues to manage the email infrastructure with the following scope:
Daily Operations
- Mailbox warmup and health monitoring
- Domain reputation tracking and optimization
- Inbox placement testing and reporting
Monthly Strategic Review
- Deliverability performance analysis
- Recommendations for volume scaling
- Customer risk profile adjustments
- New ISP policy monitoring and adaptation
Quarterly Infrastructure Planning
- Capacity planning for growth projections
- New domain acquisition and aging
- Technology stack optimization
- Compliance and regulation updates
Scaling for Continued Growth
In the 9 months following infrastructure stabilization:
- Scaled from 6.8M to 18M emails per month
- Maintained 78-83% consistent inbox placement rate
- Added 120+ new customers without major incidents
- Achieved SOC 2 compliance (email infrastructure components)
Postbox didn’t just fix our deliverability crisis—they transformed email from our biggest operational headache into a competitive advantage. The infrastructure they built and manage for us has been rock-solid even as we’ve tripled our sending volume. More importantly, their team acts as a true partner. They understand our business, not just the technical details. When we have questions about scaling or onboarding a high-volume customer, they’re proactive with recommendations before we even ask.
Lessons Learned
For AI-Powered Sales Platforms
- Don’t wait for a crisis: Proactive infrastructure management is 10x cheaper than emergency recovery
- Multi-tenant isolation is critical: One bad actor can tank reputation for hundreds of customers
- Warmup is non-negotiable: Aggressive ramping will burn domains faster than you can replace them
- Monitoring must be real-time: Deliverability issues compound hourly, not daily
- Offshore what’s not core: Your engineers should build AI features, not manage mailbox rotation
For Platform Engineering Teams
- Deliverability is a full-time job: It requires dedicated expertise, not part-time attention
- ISP relationships matter: Having escalation paths with Gmail/Outlook teams saves weeks during incidents
- Infrastructure must scale ahead of demand: Can’t add domains/mailboxes on-demand without warmup
- Compliance is mandatory: DKIM/SPF/DMARC aren’t optional for serious platforms
- Customer education prevents problems: Most issues come from users who don’t understand email limits
About This Engagement
| Client Type | Series A AI Sales Engagement Platform |
|---|---|
| Project Timeline | 8-week transformation + ongoing management |
| Engagement Model | Full infrastructure management with dedicated team |
| Investment Range | $15K-25K/month depending on volume and scope |
Services Delivered
- Emergency deliverability recovery
- Multi-tenant infrastructure design and deployment
- Mailbox pool sourcing and management
- Daily operational management
- Strategic deliverability consulting
- Engineering team training and knowledge transfer
Ready to Strengthen Your AI Sales Platform Deliverability?
If your AI-powered platform, sales engagement tool, or multi-tenant outbound product is experiencing similar deliverability challenges—or you want to avoid them entirely—let’s talk.
Free Deliverability & Infrastructure Audit
We’ll review your current setup, highlight risks, and outline how to support your next stage of growth.